Hockey Terminal
Be a GM

Compare players, 2023-24 season

At a glance

Cale Makar Roman Josi

GoalsAssistsPointsShotsHitsCorsi for %CF% relOn-ice xG %RatingChances createdShot qualityFinishingThe typical playerCale Makar: Goals, 0.27 a game, 99th percentileCale Makar: Assists, 0.90 a game, 99th percentileCale Makar: Points, 1.17 a game, 99th percentileCale Makar: Shots, 3.00 a game, 99th percentileCale Makar: Hits, 0.48 a game, 8th percentileCale Makar: Corsi for %, 53.0%, 80th percentileCale Makar: CF% rel, 0.7, 60th percentileCale Makar: On-ice xG %, 54.6%, 85th percentileCale Makar: Rating, +21.7 goals above replacement, 99th percentileCale Makar: Chances created, 0.54 xG per 60, 99th percentileCale Makar: Shot quality, 4.9% a shot, 98th percentileCale Makar: Finishing, +3.9 goals above expected, 95th percentileRoman Josi: Goals, 0.28 a game, 99th percentileRoman Josi: Assists, 0.76 a game, 97th percentileRoman Josi: Points, 1.04 a game, 99th percentileRoman Josi: Shots, 3.27 a game, 99th percentileRoman Josi: Hits, 0.56 a game, 14th percentileRoman Josi: Corsi for %, 53.4%, 84th percentileRoman Josi: CF% rel, 3.9, 91st percentileRoman Josi: On-ice xG %, 54.5%, 85th percentileRoman Josi: Rating, +16.5 goals above replacement, 98th percentileRoman Josi: Chances created, 0.55 xG per 60, 99th percentileRoman Josi: Shot quality, 4.9% a shot, 97th percentileRoman Josi: Finishing, +4.5 goals above expected, 96th percentile
02040608020406080Cale Makar 90Roman Josi 85

On the radar, each spoke runs from the lowest at the centre to the league leader at the rim, among the regulars at his position: forwards against forwards, defencemen against defencemen. The gap between two players on a spoke is the real gap between their numbers. The dashed shape is the typical player. Hover over a dot for the number. The lines are each player's points adding up, game by game.

Where they shot from

Cale Makar
Roman Josi

Darker red means more attempts from that spot, and each dot is a goal. "Show every shot" switches to a dot for each attempt, bigger for a better chance. Click a line in a key to filter its map.

The numbers

Cale Makar D, COL 2023-24 Roman Josi D, NSH
77 Games played 82
21 Goals 23
69 Assists 62
90 Points 85
1.17 Points per game 1.04
15 Plus/minus 12
231 Shots 268
9.1 Shooting % 8.6
37 Hits 46
16 Penalty minutes 45
24:46 Average ice time 24:38
Five-on-five, while he was on the ice
53.0 Corsi for % 53.4
+0.7 CF% relative to team +3.9
52.8 Fenwick for % 54.3
54.6 Expected goals for % 54.5
+3.8 xGF% relative to team +2.7
52.6 Goals for % 56.6
100.0 PDO 101.2
314 Shot attempts taken 405
Expected goals, all situations
17.1 Expected goals 18.5
0.54 Expected goals per 60 0.55
4.9% Chance per attempt 4.9%
+3.9 Goals above expected +4.5
Rating, in goals
+21.7 Goals above replacement +16.5
+3.6 Wins above replacement +2.7
+6.6 Even-strength offence +9.4
+4.5 Even-strength defence -1.4
+2.1 Power play +2.2
-0.8 Penalty kill +0.2
+3.0 Penalties -0.7
Contract
$9M Cap hit $9.059M
$100K Cap dollars per point $107K
$16.9M Worth at the going rate $13.1M
+$7.9M Value: worth minus cap hit +$4M

The better value in each stat is highlighted. Stats where more is not clearly better, such as games played, are not judged. Bars show each value against the larger of the two. What the advanced numbers mean